Monday, September 26, 2016

Writing about poetry is much easier than writing poetry, In my opinion.  For me this is because I have a stronger ability to write analytical writing, and am less inclined to writing fiction.  To write poetry one needs a creative mind and the ability to conjure up imaginary or un-experienced phenomenon.  A certain knowledge of the english language, and ability to use vocabulary that sounds aesthetic and rhymes in a pleasing way is needed to write poetry in a way that is pleasing to read and to listen to.  In order to write about poetry it takes an entirely different skill set.  Namely the ability to think analytically about a text and to critically analyze it.  These are an entirely different set of skills it requires as a writer, than it takes in order write an aesthetically pleasing poem to read.

From this experience I learned that each writer has his or her own personal strengths and they need to take advantage of them and write what they are most comfortable with writing.  Not every writer is capable of being a George R.R. Martin or the next J.K. Rowling.  I personally am admittedly not a very capable fiction writer am much more fond of analytical writing, and there is nothing wrong with that.  If a student is an awesome all around writer that’s great, but if they prefer or are more talented at a certain writing discipline than they should pursue and strengthen whatever writing style and discipline they choose.

6 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Dear Mr. Ho,

    I enjoyed reading about what you got out of the Poetry Slam experience. For me, creative writing is much easier than analytical writing. It is interesting for me as a student to see how many people there are on both sides of this spectrum. From reading the reasons for why you think this way, I agree and disagree at the same time. It seems like you enjoy certain things about writing essays, like being able to voice your own opinion of something. Or making meaning out of context and the maybe the type of pride you get from that. On the other hand, I disagree with what you said about not everyone having the same abilities as others to write masterpieces. It is good that you say that both types of writing are equally important, but I still think everyone has the ability to do anything they put their minds to.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hello Jeff,
    I find it interesting that you said writing about poetry is easier than writing poetry because I agree. When writing about poetry you know the structure to follow and you know which guide lines to follow and the steps to take are ones you’ve been thought. When writing your own poetry you don’t have any guidelines and you just write what you choose and it can be hard to come across and you are left to decide everything and it can feel like a lot of pressure. I also agree it write poetry it does take an entirely different skill set. It is far more complex and difficult then one might think. I agree writing fiction takes a specific set of skills that some master wonderfully but for me it is difficult to write fiction or poems so amazingly as others did but it was a fun experience. I think I’ am more comfortable with the analytical work then the creative. I’ am not sure if I like it more or if that’s just what my mind is so accustom too. I really enjoyed writing the poetry even though I found it extremely difficult. So I find it interesting that you like the analytical because I like how I’ am so familiar with the structure of the analytical but loved the experience of the poem.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Jeff,

    I agree that I get a lot more enjoyment out of analyzing and interpreting poetry rather than writing about it. I feel like when I'm able to analyze a text I get an inside look into someone else's mind and emotions. It's a very intimate experience and I love being able to interpret a text using my own life experiences and relate it back to myself. Because often than not when I find a poem or text that I find relatable, it makes me feel like I'm not alone and that someone else out there feels the same way I do.

    I also agree that it is a major skill to be able to produce something of fiction out of nothing. I admire all the great writers you mentioned because they had the mental ability and creativity to make these wonderful works, and I believe that if we see students who possess these kind of abilities we need to encourage them to pursue their dreams and share with the world.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Jeff,

    What you discussed on the Poetry Slam I found agreeable, and I can definitely see your point of view on the matter. I too, find the analytical side of writing about poetry a bit easier but I don't exactly know the conclusion why. I find the breakdown of a poem easier perhaps because I've been writing papers all my life or maybe it's just luck. I also had fun with the creative process though, and I couldn't help but smile at your George Martin reference which sums up a valid point.

    I do believe poetry needs a bit of an acquired taste, or in this sense, an acquired ear. Not all poetry is equal, and like we experienced in class, some are better read aloud by others and each carry their own message in terms of weight and personal connection. With that, I think poetry seems to hit a message faster and deeper, but maybe not at the cost of a novel's buildup and structure, but to each their own.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Mr. Ho, kudos on being brave and performing your haiku brilliantly! I believe your action really enabled the rest of the class to enter this activity with less reservation, and I honestly really enjoyed your poem.
    As you have mentioned, I also agree on the fact that writing a poem requires a different set of skills that I believe may be harnessed by young writers to improve in not only their creativity, but their arguments as well. Much like analytic essays, a poem also has a point that it wishes to convey- or an emotion. A poem can go a long way to impact future writers and even texts by setting examples and precedence for history.
    I think practicing different types of writing like we have done will go a long way in helping us understand the creative aspect of writing and teaching our future students as well.

    ReplyDelete